David Eggleton
Mark Adams: A survey | He Kohinga Whakaahu by Sarah Farrar (Massey University Press, 2025), 359pp, $80; Aotearoa Light: Moments of wonder and realisation in New Zealand wilderness by Peter Laurenson (Bateman Books, 2025), 260pp, $70; Slow Burn Ahi Tāmau | Women and Photography Māreikura Whakaahua by Lissa Mitchell (Te Papa Press, 2026), 232pp, $35
Once, the power of a photograph lay in its veracity, its fidelity, its authoritative rendering of visual fact. Documentary photographs were clues, evidence to make deductions from, their mute witness speaking volumes. Now, we treat such photographs with scepticism, even as we scrutinise them. In an age of a glut of manipulated images and a daily tsunami of digital media, along with the arrival of AI, the status of the photograph as evidence of authenticity is constantly being challenged. A photograph is no longer about answers but about questions. A photograph requires explanation or justification and needs to be placed and catalogued within specific histories.
Mark Adams: A survey | He Kohinga Whakaahu, put together by Sarah Farrar, head curator at Auckland Art Gallery Toi o Tāmaki, is the bulky catalogue of a national travelling exhibition—which is still on tour—of the images of photographer Mark Adams, who, since the early 1970s, has been creating important and distinctive large-format documentary photographs that consider Aotearoa New Zealand’s colonial and post-colonial legacies as knotty cross-cultural intersections. Adams, using an old-fashioned view camera, revisits locations and revises assumptions of British Empire photographers such as the Burton Brothers, Daniel Mundy and Josiah Martin, carefully and methodically, while acknowledging: ‘In the end, you can only decolonise your own head.’
The notion of ‘the survey’ is an apt term to describe these works, as the book reveals Adams to be an attentive observer who has self-consciously worked over the course of his career to make images that track and resist the colonial-settler gaze—and indeed the very notion of land surveying that began with Captain Cook’s expeditions and their grand narrative of great expectations from new territories. Introductory essays by Ngāhuia Te Awekotuku and Sarah Farrar provide a framing context for this.
These photographs, then, are a form of politics by other means, where Adams uses, with subtlety, the aura or patina—‘the silver sublime’—of nineteenth-century landscape photography in a contrary or rebellious manner, so that each of his images ends up not endorsing the myth of ‘an empty land’, but as an ironic examination of ‘scars on the land’ made by extractive industries, pastoralism, tourism and so on. The photographs are always meticulously crafted symphonies of natural light, composition and timing, whose clarity on this monumental scale is reminiscent of that of the American New Topographic photographers of the 1970s who focused on altered landscapes. But Adams goes beyond them in his preoccupation with what is visible yet marred and confronting, to turn the landscape into a cultural fault line.
Adams grew up in Christchurch and both his grandfather and his father were keen amateur photographers. He attended the University of Canterbury School of Art between 1967 and 1970, where he mostly taught himself photography, as the school did not at the time have a photography department. From early on, partly because of student radicalism, Adams was interested in images that expose contradictions and subversive narratives: narratives expressing a counter-discourse to the mainstream.
The selection of full-page photographs in the book opens with three silver-toned, expressionist-style portraits by Adams of the artist Tony Fomison, looming into the lens. Fomison, though of the same age, was an inspirational figure for Adams as an iconoclastic image-maker and social provocateur. He was an anti-conformist of working-class origins, pushing back against middle-class consumerist aspirations. Oscillating between brassy and fey, but always combative, Fomison offered the example of a sustained intensity of artistic purpose, as someone already interested in Māori and Polynesian culture. Adams here also documents his house in Ponsonby as a sequence of shrine-like rooms containing shelves crammed with curious objects. The quiddities and idiosyncrasies of Fomison’s domestic spaces as dark caverns are memorably picked out by the eyeballing lens of Adams’s big camera. At the same time, Adams himself had begun focusing on Māori churches, pā sites and archaeological middens, especially after he moved to Whangārei in 1974.
Fomison was also responsible for introducing Adams to the small community of customary Samoan tattoo artists—notably Sulu‘ape Paulo II—who had arrived in Auckland as part of the Pasifika diaspora and who remained committed tufuga ta tatau, or master tattooists, practising their craft in suburban living rooms as an assertion of ethnic identity. The book contains a representative selection of this sequence of ethnographic images, now recognised as a watershed moment in New Zealand photography. As Adams ventures into a contested cultural milieu, he places Auckland in a Pasifika context in a revolutionary way for the time. The images confirm his role as a kind of revisionist explorer, or map-maker, respectfully depicting rites of initiation, where scarified or ink-needled bodies—bruised and bloodstained by traditional tatau tools, and lying prone on pandanus mats placed over carpets in prosaic lounges decorated in Polynesian style—attest to another problematic cross-cultural interface.
What also becomes apparent as you leaf through the images in this book is the importance of collaborations and invitations to participate in projects. Adams began, for example, his Rotorua series (1977–2000) as a result of the institutional support of John Perry, director of the Rotorua Art Gallery, who invited him to depict the intertwined nature of Māori taonga and Pākehā interventions in the Rotorua district, showing the way tourism has warped and altered the landscape, as in the book’s cover image of the Toot and Whistle Steam Railway Park, photographed in 1986. Incongruous juxtapositions—a tapu or sacred rock stranded on a verge beside a state highway; a stone bust of Queen Victoria atop a post or pou depicting a Māori carved head—are turned into ironical critiques. These lucid, coolly distanced photographs draw conflicting symbols into the same frame.
In 1997, Adams was asked by the history curator at the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa to photograph all the sites where Te Tiriti o Waitangi was signed. This proved a complex task and remains incomplete. Adams, always intent on respecting the mana and dignity of those he interacts with, negotiated over a number of years to obtain approval from local kaumātua. What this series of photographs suggests most is the shimmering, mirage-like nature of the Treaty-signing process, with its contrary and perhaps still unresolved meanings.
In the late 1980s, in conjunction with Ngāi Tahu and the iwi’s Waitangi Tribunal claims process, Adams, working with historian Harry Evison, began documenting important historic sites across Te Waipounamu. One might call these photographs elephantine, both for their sense of scale—their sheer immensity—and for their sense of never forgetting. The wairua of place and the colossal weight of continuous time are strongly registered in the photograph titled ‘19.05.1989 Te Ana o Hineraki. Moa Bone Point Cave. Redcliffs. Ōtautahi Christchurch. Te Waipounamu South Island’, photographed from within, as the arch of the cave roof seems to bear down while the mouth of the cave is barely open to admit the blinding glare of daylight. Here, truly, the magnetism of place exerts a spiritual force that feels forbiddingly massive. Another image from the same series implies the wairua of place has been desecrated: ‘30.03.1992 Alliance freezing works and Mataura paper mill. Te Rere o Te Aunui. Mataura Falls. Murihiku Southland. Te Waipounamu South Island’ reveals, hulking, brutish and grim, the industrial structures on either side of the Falls, which look both like sinister factories and dilapidated temples. The image is an admonishing, biblical sermon, as Mammon discharges its waste products into the waters, and the up-tilted view of the witnessing sky makes the truth seem self-evident. Here, landscape is a remnant of the imperial colonial pageant: ruins in the making, a damaged psychic space.
In 1993 Adams met the Australian anthropologist Nicholas Thomas for the first time and they began spontaneously planning a long-term project—‘Cook’s sites’—which would eventually take them to all the key locations around the world associated with the three Captain Cook expeditions, beginning with the two sites in New Zealand where Cook and his crew came ashore in March 1773 and interacted with the flora and fauna and the local inhabitants. As Thomas explains in his essay ‘That Other Kind of Witnessing: An afterword’, about their trip to Fiordland: ‘On the small hill that Cook named Astronomer’s Point, cleared by the marines to facilitate astronomical observation, there were residues of the brief visit: the stumps of trees cut down were still there.’
Seeking out and compassing round panoramic vistas with his view camera in search of traces of the past—which, as William Faulkner famously said, isn’t dead; it’s not even past—Adams himself is enacting the process of monument-making with his photographs. In Fiordland, retracing Cook’s visit, he turns the foliage into freaks of fancy, its fretted patterns making flitting shapes through which the light flares; or else the hills are shrouded and moody, as if brooding, mist and vapour clinging to their slopes. Adams and Thomas also travelled to Berlin, Göttingen and Oxford, where Adams photographed relics of Cook’s expeditions preserved in institutions and museums. He went on to photograph the grounds of the Royal Observatory at Greenwich in London to make evident the connection with Cook’s astronomical observations at Tamatea in Fiordland, and Farrar discusses this connection in detail in her essay.
Adams shuffles his images to draw attention to how interpretations change over time and in the light of new knowledge. His images nurture cross-weavings of associations without providing final answers. Witness the memorial kitsch statue of Captain Cook in the colour photograph taken in Cairns, Queensland: it shows a poised and outsized cartoonish figure, inhabiting a weird realm of its own; towering over a nearby camper van, Cook stares into the distance as if embodying the imperial gaze at the end of its tether.
· · ·
The passion for the environment—and for photography—is unmistakable in Aotearoa Light: Moments of wonder and realisation in New Zealand wilderness by Peter Laurenson. Taking us along, thanks to crisp digital photography, it progresses from riverbeds to mountain peaks, travels from seashores to lakeshores, treks across tussock lands, and tramps through forests, thus establishing, as the text declares, ‘seven distinctive natural landscapes’.
Laurenson, currently editor of the Federated Mountain Club’s Backcountry magazine, tells us: ‘It took me countless hours to create this book, often requiring intense periods in total focus to mesh my images, trip experiences, wider perspectives, information and chapter structure into a cohesive narrative.’ The result is undeniably extraordinary, conveying a genuine sense of immersive journeying in a manner that refreshes the terms ‘cosmic’ and ‘planetary’. This book, in a sense, idealises the landscape, but its message of conservation and the necessity to preserve the ecological harmonies of our ‘wilderness’ rings true. It’s a compendium of remote wild places that are literally precious and increasingly rare. They are also photographed in a way that makes them figuratively precious: landscape images as jewel-like collector’s pieces to savour. Partly this is a result of Laurenson’s studious but perhaps sometimes overdetermined use of Photoshop, where ever more powerful software offers increasing enhancement beyond normal human vision.
But photography itself, of course, is a kind of fabrication and always involves manipulation of the optical to varying degrees in pursuit of ways of seeing that produce trust and understanding and agreement from the viewer. Laurenson affirms the status of the photograph while also inflating the currency of the image with tweaked colouration so as to emphasise heightened emotionalism. It’s a delicate balancing act, then, between the potentially garish and the magical actuality of what it was like to be in the great outdoors, apprehending landscape as a whole-body experience.
Ultimately, the chromatic vivacity is reined in to emphasise the morphology of the land, the kinetic flow of ridges and rivers, with the overpowering radiance of bright sunlight tamed so as to make sense of terrain features otherwise in shadow. So the colour notes are not dissonant but melodious; the tinges of purple or mauve, the infernal reds of cloud-draped sunsets and the heavenly blues of clear skies at dawn are photographed to bring out what’s already there rather than serving to transfigure in pursuit of personal symbolism. One enjoys the carnivalesque shift of the seasons, the fairground rollercoaster feel of storms and winds sweeping through. Laurenson nails down the fleeting effects of the meteorological with nuanced skill.
Sure, there are some pictorialist conventions observed, but whether trudging up slopes or speedily descending them, whether photographing dawn from high vantage points in the mountains or fungi down at ankle level on the forest floor, Aotearoa Light conveys a genuine sense of awe on its pilgrimage through the glory and grandeur of our natural world. Laurenson—with a succession of boon companions, notably his tramping comrade, fellow author and photographer Shaun Barnett, who tragically died of a brain tumour in 2024—delivers us into the midst of things, memorably the atmosphere of the goblin forest in Tararua Forest Park, with bracing clarity and a sense of the euphoric. These are landscapes at once rugged and vulnerable but always uplifting, caught in light by turns slanting, glinting, raking, bouncing and dappling, while tiny puffball clouds spiral around the maunga Taranaki, or a waterfall cascades silkily in the Catlins.
· · ·
In Slow Burn Ahi Tāmau | Women and Photography Māreikura Whakaahua, Lissa Mitchell, photography curator at the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa, provides a history of photography by women and non-binary artists from the 1960s to the present day, using the concept of feminism less as a fixed ideology than as a transformative set of sometimes contradictory narratives. Her book, a catalogue of over 150 works by fifty artists produced in association with an exhibition at Te Papa of the same name, contains photographic imagery in a myriad of formats—portrait prints, Polaroids, video stills, cyanotypes, photo-collages, photographs inset in jewellery and family photo albums, as well as an assortment of artists’ photobooks.
To order this mass of images, Mitchell has divided the book into four thematically linked sections, where photographs might visually connect, collide, or even seem to slide at times into one of the other, somewhat arbitrarily titled sections. Always, the book offers the consideration of photographs both as physical objects in their own right and as examples of larger interconnective archives between artists with strategies and aims in common.
After a preamble that discusses pioneering women photographers, the contemporary canonical framing ostensibly begins in the 1960s with the inclusion of Ans Westra, but the single image by her in the book is ‘32 Highbury Road’ from 2001. This colour photograph of a charred and scorched room might have prompted the book’s title. Certainly, it has a still-smouldering quality that rhymes and chimes with ‘slow burn’. However, the phrase implies many things, including belated self-awareness and a pictorialist photographic technique. What one might call the foundation images in the book—Mitchell uses the term ‘touchstones’—are derived from a 1982 touring exhibition and catalogue Views/Exposures, put together by the then National Art Gallery and featuring five male and five female photographers. The cover image of Slow Burn is taken from Anne Noble’s ‘Night Hawk’ series, which was included in Views/Exposures.
Photography as performance, as theatre, as masquerade, was a central motif in women’s photography in the 1980s, and Mitchell includes images by Anne Noble, Fiona Pardington, Christine Webster and Di ffrench, showing these photographers taking on and adapting a taboo iconography, mixing religion and seduction, challenging patriarchal Christianity, revelling in the angelic and the devilish, depicting holy sinners in rhapsodic states—in short, asserting autonomy. Other photographers of the era shown here were working in related ways to create charged moments. Victoria Ginn’s shamanistic images evoke erotic communion with earth, wind, sea and sky, while Margaret Dawson uses costume to suggest suburban disaffection, and Adrienne Martyn depicts a subdued or self-questioning melancholia, as in her 1983 photographic portrait of painter Joanna Paul.
Another photographer active in the 1980s, Elizabeth Leyland, emphasises—like Anne Noble—the nocturnal and similarly references film noir. The ferocity of Leyland’s flash-lit photography captures the midnight facade of a deserted inner-city street as if probed by sinister searchlights, snap-freezing the shadows and loading the scene with a haunting sense of consequence.
Photography is the art of fixing a shadow, declared the Victorian photographer William Henry Fox Talbot, and various photographers in Slow Burn use variations of this idea to plumb visual enigmas or create symbolic resonances and fine shades of feeling out of shadows and the penumbral. Zahra Killeen-Chance, working with Solomon Mortimer, pairs gelatin silver photo prints from the series The Sea Sets Beneath the Ocean (2021/2023) to show silhouettes of two heads bowed in thought, a delicate interaction that brings to mind Diane Arbus’s claim that a photograph is a secret about a secret.
Stella Brennan employs her family heirlooms—a set of old glass-plate negatives—to make photographs whose emulsion has pitted and peeled to suggest ghostly ectoplasm that looks at once luminous and decayed. Using an obsolete technology, she is reviving spectres, or possibly family traumas. Likewise interested in the ontological being of old photographs and techniques to restore them, Annemarie Hope-Cross conjures up ‘darkroom treasures’ using pigment prints and antique papers. The resultant fogged images are still lifes of bottles, jars and flowers that seem to be pullulating with stains and streaks and blots and blurs.
Jane Wilcox, in her 2022 photobook Between Dog and Wolf, photographing a flowering tree at dusk, reveals twilight as the violet hour, a moment of transition when the atmosphere becomes tremulous and everything takes on an air of ambiguity. There’s a folkloric element to this, bringing to mind mythopoetic stories of changelings, which other photographers take up in different ways, using folklore. Tia Ranginui repositions the pūrākau of a taniwha in a modish subdivision with uncanny valley vibes, while Ann Shelton’s suite of photographs makes ikebana arrangements the starting point for an ongoing visual essay on botanical efflorescence as the herald of folkloric accounts about the medicinal properties of plants.
But sometimes photographers simply capitalise on a sense of comic possibilities in the everyday, as exemplified in Nela Fletcher’s 2023 series Fitting In, which might have been inspired by the online viral phenomenon of planking. A young woman is depicted variously holding onto or balancing on structures in stairwells, in children’s playgrounds or between downpipes. Her anti-gravity act—trying to fit in—is hilariously precarious; it’s a kind of street choreography, turning awkwardness into an art form. In the end, Slow Burn is a fantastically rich resource, signposting the diversity and energy of contemporary women’s photography in this country and serving as an index to the exploration of further riches in Te Papa’s photographic collections.
DAVID EGGLETON is a writer based in Ōtepoti Dunedin. He is the current editor of The Landfall Tauraka Review.
Hi David,
I would like to repost this review on my facebook page, and encourage PhotoForum Online to do the same if they haven’t done so already?
Would that be ok by you?
I’ve been digging into your ‘Into the Light …’ and always find it stimulating.
Kind Regards,
John Turner
Yes, of course, please share! Thanks for your interest and support.