• HOME
  • LANDFALL TAURAKA
  • COMPETITIONS
  • ABOUT

The Landfall Tauraka Review

The Landfall Tauraka Review: Aotearoa New Zealand books in review

Fitting In

1 May 2025 Leave a Comment

Jack Ross

The Life and Opinions of Kartik Popat by Brannavan Gnanalingam (Lawrence & Gibson, 2024), 297pp, $30

This is certainly a very timely novel. At a moment when bizarre political twists and turns come so fast that we can hardly keep up with the craziness, a retrospective look at the origin stories of certain all-pervasive social-media-driven ideologies might well be salutary for all of us.

It’s a timely book, but The Life and Opinions of Kartik Popat is also a book about time. The first chapter is dated 1984, and the last is dated 2024. The first chapter is called ‘I’ve Been Writing’ and the last chapter is ‘I’ve Been Thinking’. For some readers, at least, that will trigger a little trip down memory lane, recalling the titles of Richard Prebble’s infamous 1996 and 1999 ACT manifestos. Brannavan Gnanalingam, too, has been writing. In the 14 years since the publication of his first novel, called, appropriately enough, Getting Under Sail, he’s published another seven: an impressive total by any standards.

Like the protagonist of V.S. Naipaul’s debut novel The Mystic Masseur (1957)—which is the cautionary tale of a thwarted Trinidadian writer who exploits the gullibility of his celebrity clients to climb the social totem pole—Kartik Popat, Gnanalingam’s own anti-hero, also begins as a ‘creative’ of sorts. Popat’s baulked ambitions as a filmmaker centre around his projected feature film, And Jack, and his ambitions have been gradually eroded away by the ever more effective prostitution of his talents, firstly in the service of the New Zealand political establishment, and then through involvement with the Anti-Vaxxer movement.

In the novel’s bio-note, Gnanalingam informs us that And Jack is the title of a real 2004 short film, ‘written and directed by Brannavan Gnanalingam, Jonny Thompson and Steve Wakeem’. This autobiographical aspect seems integral to his writing. Each of his first seven novels appears to have been based on a particular period in the author’s life: Getting Under Sail (2011) on a trip from Morocco to Ghana, which included being detained as a murder suspect; You Should Have Come Here When You Were Not Here (2013) on his time in Paris between 2012 and 2013; Credit in the Straight World (2015), the first of his books to be set in New Zealand, on the global financial crisis as seen from down under. And so on.

Again and again, I felt these uncomfortable rhymes with experience as Gnanalingam, through his anti-hero Popat, forced me to relive Helen Clark’s painful last years in the Beehive; then the rise of the ‘smiling assassin’, John Key; and then the ghastly death throes of Jacinda Ardern’s coalition of kindness. You can’t take even the most tangential interest in New Zealand politics and not find your worst suspicions about our elected representatives thoroughly vindicated by Popat’s half-hearted apologia pro vita sua—his defence of his actions and conduct.

However, it’s the pitiless grimness of Popat’s early years—bullied and despised in high school without the slightest prospect of reprieve from being cast into the dungeon of ethnicity—that really rings true. It was, admittedly, a long time ago. Change is possible. Undoubtedly, though, there’s bound to be even more knee-jerk racism on display now than during Popat’s miserable childhood.

Which brings us neatly to the question of what exactly Gnanalingam is seeking to achieve with this novel. He’s explained in some detail, in an article in the Spinoff, the moment of inspiration for his book when he watched an Indian American podcast host (and former Republican presidential candidate) interviewing a notoriously racist influencer, a white woman, who began by praising him for being so ‘articulate’: ‘I guess I can call you “articulate” because you’re not an American black.’ After they had a good old chortle at the idea of such an obvious oxymoron, she threw in the kicker: ‘But I still would not have voted for you, because you’re an Indian.’ As Gnanalingam explains in his article:

You can grease up to racist folks by doing some of the heavy lifting for them, but they’ll still never view you as one of them. You’re just the hired help. And they’ll still view you as a loser … I wanted to capture this ugliness in my novel, grift off the grift, and imagine a New Zealand equivalent. Presumably mocking other minorities must be rewarding in its own way (putting aside the societal impacts)—power, money, royalties from tank-top sales, and kudos from the worst people who’d discard you the moment they don’t need you—and all you have to pay is your self-respect.

Perhaps the question Gnanalingam’s novel sets out to answer, then, is this: How do you get from here to there? How do you start off as a proud child, shaped by community and family values, and turn into a grovelling toady for the modern-day equivalent of slave-owners? Explaining that is certainly going to be tricky.

A straightforward first-person life-and-times narrative might have seemed the obvious approach. But there are problems as well as advantages with that form. The Mystic Masseur, for instance, is not told in the first person. Its eponymous protagonist is observed from a discreet distance by a very judgmental contemporary (who sounds, curiously enough, a lot like Naipaul himself). The apparent focus of Kartik Popat’s tale is made out to be Popat himself—his struggles and the appalling people he’s met, virtually all of whom seem to have betrayed him in some way. And I presume the real focus is on the morally bankrupt, self-serving nature of his story.

The ever more degrading compromises he makes in the desperate quest to be accepted by the complacent reactionary racist society around him—which lead him eventually to posting off packages of multi-vitamins as Covid remedies at the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, and even renting an (admittedly unoccupied) tent in the Anti-Vax encampment in Wellington—are chronicled by Gnalalingam through the voice of Kartik in grim detail.

‘There need never, at the worst, be any difficulty about the things advantageously chuckable for art,’ said Henry James. Gnalalingam has, understandably, chucked out little—certainly none of the rage and disgust he still feels at the self-satisfied complacency and smugness of Pākehā society. This is something (I would guess) that he experienced continuously as a child, and no doubt still experiences to this day.

It’s not that this is bad material, by any means. On the contrary, the trouble is that it’s too interesting. My fascination with Popat’s early life and humiliations far outweighed any indignation I felt down the track at his Anti-Vaxxer shenanigans.

And given how little of the book is actually devoted to his final incarnation as an online stirrer and random conduit of contradictory misinformation, it’s not surprising that it’s the vomiting subhuman MPs he was forced to serve as a parliamentary staffer who remain the truly unforgettable parts of his story. Popat himself begins to fade to a mere reporter on their infamy.

Satire is a particularly demanding form in this respect. It’s not by accident that its most effective examples exhibit a kind of meme-like intensity: Jonathan Swift’s cartoonish Lilliputians and Brobdingnagians, for instance; or Evelyn Waugh’s battling war correspondents in his novel Scoop. These are not subtle narratives, by any means, but they’re effective because of the burning indignation that compels each brutal line.

Swift, Waugh, Orwell had something vital to say about the human condition, and they said it in the snappiest, most telling way possible. Is the same true of Gnanalingam? His own political satire, while grounded in disgust at the all too human, seems to me to lack the necessary counterbalance of a moral centre and the possibility of grace. Unlike Swift—or, for that matter, Laurence Sterne, whose digressive and eccentric Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy presumably inspired his title—he leaves us with nothing to believe in.

So, in the absence of anything to hold to in the amoral vacuum that is the world of Kartik Popat (or, if you prefer, of contemporary Aotearoa New Zealand), we’re left only with the narrator himself. It’s not that it’s possible to love—let alone respect—the scheming Kartik Popat (or ‘Pooh-pat’ or ‘Tikka’, as he’s variously nicknamed), but it’s certainly easy enough for the reader to understand and even (at times) empathise with him.

Kartik’s own self-justifying analysis of his surroundings is, always, fatally flawed by the basic futility of his desire to fit in: ‘fit in’, that is, with a bunch of subhuman cretins, brutes who are limned with all the bitterness of experience. But then that, too, is a profoundly human trait. Nor is the novel’s inconclusive ending—Kartik’s new job as an insurance adjustor with instructions to deny as many storm claims as possible—exactly calculated to enlighten us. It’s always someone else’s agenda he’s following.

Popat may well be a figure for our times—I fear that he is—but unfortunately that doesn’t make the novel he stars in as coherent as it could have been. For all its many undoubted merits and insights, it’s an uneven read, sometimes too inclusive, sometimes too detailed, sometimes too summary—but always swathed in run-on verbiage that sears and scours rather than heals.

Yet, even if it’s not quite the taut, targeted satire it set out to be, The Life and Opinions of Kartik Popat is still valuable as a relentless chronicle of ‘the time of our time’ (to borrow a phrase from that great Satan, Norman Mailer). There are some scenes here I doubt I’ll ever be able to scrub out of my memory, no matter how hard I try.


JACK ROSS is the author of six poetry collections, four novels and five books of short fiction, most recently Haunts (Lasavia, 2024). He was managing editor of Poetry New Zealand from 2014–20 and has edited numerous other anthologies, books and literary journals. He lives with his wife, crafter and art-writer Bronwyn Lloyd, in Mairangi Bay on Auckland’s North Shore.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Related

Filed Under: fiction

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent reviews

  • Feby Idrus reviews Stakes: Dracula and the secret to happiness by Noelle McCarthy
  • Vaughan Rapatahana reviews Kupu Whenua by Hana Buchanan; Portrait by Jackson McCarthy (Auckland University Press, 2026); and Lady of the Murals: The prose poems 2005–2025 by Stephen Oliver
  • Jeffrey Holman reviews On the Highway of the Stories of the Gods by Martin Edmond
  • Michelle Elvy reviews One Foot on the Bottom by Mary Macpherson and Thread Between Darkness & Light by Stella Brennan
  • Max Oettli reviews New Zealand Photography Collected: 175 years of photography in Aotearoa by Athol McCredie

Review archive

Reviews by genre

Sign up to receive new reviews

Subscribe via Substack

Otago University Press

Monthly reviews of Aotearoa New Zealand literature. The companion to Landfall Tauraka.

© 2025 Otago University Press Te Whare Tā o Ōtākou Whakaihu Waka
Copyright & Disclaimer | Privacy
Website by Arts Net

Loading Comments...