Siobhan Harvey
Hiding Places by Lynley Edmeades (Otago University Press, 2025), 244pp, $35; Eddie Sparkle’s Bridal Taxi by Frankie McMillan (Canterbury University Press, 2025), 132pp, $30
There are many ways to tell a story, and the more stories we tell, the more ways we find to tell them. Three decades ago, when I first embraced the task—the graft, the joy—of being a writer, the standard approaches to composition seemed limited: fiction (novels or short stories); poetry; biography. Perhaps, in time and with a literary career sufficiently illustrious, a memoir might be penned. But, for the most part, the expectation for emerging and mid-career writers was one of convention: you write verse, or you write prose. Thankfully, much has changed since.
Of course, the traditions remain, but—as if to confirm literature as an enchanted garden in which beautiful, exciting and colourful things might be cultivated—writers have uncovered inventive ways to cross-pollinate. Hybrid texts have resulted, combining truth-telling with fiction, poetry with essay, memoir with appendices, letters with lyrics. In this, form has become more than a fusion; it’s become a musical scale, something to conjure with. So now, narratives—be they conventional fiction or unconventional bricolage—can range from the epic to the micro, with many increments in between. This is a testament to the power of story to endure, which is also to say, to continue to resonate. The possibilities of the hybrid are evident in two new books of creative writing by two New Zealand women writers: Hiding Places by Ōtepoti Dunedin author, academic and editor Lynley Edmeades; and Eddie Sparkle’s Bridal Taxi by Ōtautahi Christchurch author Frankie McMillan. Each work is a narrative of multiple forms and literary techniques, and each is exciting and innovative.
To reduce a multifaceted book to a simple component is never easy, as many will understand if they’ve ever faced the daunting task of devising a synopsis for their magnum opus. At its core, though, what can be said of Lynley Edmeades’ Hiding Places is that it’s a book about motherhood: the experience, expectation, pathology, literature, constraint, liberation, dream, struggle, pain—and yes, wonder—of that most personal and contestable of matters. This book is structured as a series of concise parts, which sounds as if it’s a short offering when, in fact, at 244 pages, it’s quite the reverse. It’s this expansiveness, the wide-ranging nature of Hiding Places, which best evokes the far-reaching intent of its author to realise what a story can be. For though its elements may be succinct, they bring together memoir-style meditations on pre- and postpartum experience; excerpts from the influential infant-raising New Zealand text Feeding and Care for Baby by Truby King (1913); family letters; imaginary epistolary elements; covert medical records, along with assorted ruminations on writing and various editorial exchanges. If this sounds heady, the topic of motherhood sustains an engaging read, as this excerpt illustrates:
You find yourself thinking about a conversation you had with your physio the other day about mother guilt. Do you remember anything from your first two or three years though? she had asked. You don’t need to worry, your boy won’t remember anything and won’t have anything to resent you for.
By this logic, L says, we could just have put S in a cupboard for the first few years, just kept him alive.
The tenderness of experience is also evident in the imaginative letters the protagonist, at odds with her mother about how she’s raising the newborn, composes to the author Kate Zambreno (‘K’), ergo:
Dear K
Will you be my mother?
Thanks in advance.
Regards
More broadly, K and the inventive connections to her explored in Hiding Places serve to magnify and examine how others—writers, academics, relatives—evoke and inform the maternal experience. Sometimes, as above, there’s a tenderness to a one-sided exchange with K; at others, such a relationship is fraught, as when, for instance, the author writes a list of confronting doubts related to the physical and psychological experience of motherhood, which, the reader knows, will never be resolved.
Offsetting the epistolary are impersonal intertextual elements, such as extracts from King’s historical work and redacted familial psychiatric records. Though the latter speak to a kinship whose past frames current struggles, the former make for perhaps the most confronting of readings, namely because the passages remind the reader of the inflexible, overbearing and misogynistic attitudes towards the birthing and child-raising processes:
The pregnant woman should be radiantly healthy, happy, and uplifted. If she will only take plenty of outdoor exercise, and lead a bright, healthy, active life, she need have no fear for herself or the baby … Ask any capable farmer what steps he takes to ensure the health and safety of the mothers of his flocks and herds, and he will tell you free range in the open air, and daily exercise are the first essentials …
What results, then, isn’t just a narrative blending of fiction and fact, letter and literature, storytelling and crisp poetic prose, but also a synthesis of intricate tones and emotions experienced when devising, as the author prefaces her book, ‘a story about a book about becoming a mother’.
· · ·
Frankie McMillan is described on the back cover of her new collection as ‘one of the leading writers of the short-short form in Aotearoa New Zealand’. Indeed, her numerous annual selections for best micro-fiction anthologies, not to mention the awards and residencies bestowed upon her, testify to this. As does this seventh book, the evocatively titled Eddie Sparkle’s Bridal Taxi. As its name suggests, the ‘short-short form’ is a compact story told in poetry, fiction, or a fusion of both, in less than two pages (and frequently even shorter). As McMillan’s short-short forms evidence, their concision belies the deep craft needed to compose them. Take the titular opening tale:
I went through twelve little brides that first year.
A bride has to look fresh riding on the bonnet of the taxi, satin streamers comin’ off her shoulders, her sweet face braced to the wind. Those dolls took a buffering out there in all weathers …
The focalisation not only suggests a well-wrought voice and perspective, but a whole backstory is implied by what’s revealed. That’s the great skill of the short-short form: how the writer enables what’s on the page to convey—through inference, detail, dialogue and so forth—the novel-sized narrative beyond it. This is also evident elsewhere, as in the tales ‘The Knife Thrower’s Daughter’, ‘Break Up’ and ‘My Mother Who Flew Under the Radar’, for example. So much of the depth of the short-short work here depends on language, especially the author’s ability to derive invention from association, as the opening of ‘My Mother Who Flew Under the Radar’ illustrates:
My mother was not the sort of woman who liked funerals or men in suits or uniforms telling her what she could or couldn’t do, and if they knocked on the door with their clipboards, their documents or census forms, she was not the sort of woman to comply …
Repetition, cadence, run-ons: these are all poetic devices, and McMillan draws them expertly into her prose. She even frames her stories in verse form with the likes of ‘Past Jack Koo’s Shop: A faux pantoum’.
Like Edmeades’ Hiding Places, much of the subject matter in Eddie Sparkle’s Bridal Taxi centres on womanhood, relationships, family and children. And like Edmeades, McMillan ensures her work is threaded with a medley of emotions. Note the poignant beginning of ‘Why I Watch My Mouth When My Wolf Sister Comes to Stay’:
At first, we are fierce with happiness, my wolf sister bounds through the door swinging her suitcase, god, let’s have a drink, she cries and I keep filling her glass and later when her clumsy paw knocks the red wine over the new bench I don’t say anything, instead I grab the cloth real quick and wipe the wine off with a flourish as if to say, how easy is that, sis, how easy is it to clean up after yourself …
Consequently, the impact and atmosphere of each work is never a comfortable replication of the one before or after it. So, the measured savagery of ‘Why I Watch My Mouth When My Wolf Sister Comes to Stay’ is followed by the lyrical, almost elegiac ‘A Kind of Faith’, which concludes:
I want to
say I’ve seen
a photo
of your high wire
man.
so thin
he passes
through clouds,
his balancing
pole
a crucifix
across his chest.
McMillan packs a great deal into 132 pages: different topics, different structures, different sentiments. But it’s the ability of such richness and variety to linger long after in the reader’s mind that is the greatest achievement of a book derived from the short-short form.
SIOBHAN HARVEY is the author of nine books. Her latest, a memoir entitled What We Remember, What We Forget, will be published by Otago University Press in May 2026.
Leave a Reply